St. Johns County, Florida
Butler Beach Real Estate and Local Guide
Butler Beach is a small Anastasia Island beach community between the Atlantic Ocean and the Matanzas River, with an older, largely retiree population. Ranked Realty pairs verified local data with the agents who know Butler Beach best.
About the area
Living in Butler Beach, FL
Founded by Frank B. Butler as the only beach between Jacksonville and Daytona Beach open to African Americans during segregation.
The housing market
Homes in Butler Beach
- About 85% of occupied homes are owner-occupied.
- About half of housing units, roughly 50%, are single-family detached homes.
- The median home value is about $469,100.
Landmarks and lifestyle
What makes Butler Beach home
Butler Beach
Historic Anastasia Island beach founded in the 1920s as a resort open to Black residents
St. Johns County Black History Trail
Butler Beach is a featured stop on the county Black History Trail
Frank Butler Park East
Atlantic beachfront county park with restrooms, showers, grills, and a pavilion
Frank Butler Park West
Matanzas River county park on the Intracoastal Waterway with picnic areas
For agents
Own Butler Beach in search and in AI
Buyers now ask Google and AI for a local agent. Claim your free Ranked Realty page for Butler Beach, FL, get listed in our directory, and upgrade any time to a full AI-optimized site that gets you found and recommended.
Local facts on this page are verified against public sources as part of the AppWT local-data project. Data reflects the most recent available figures.