Benton County, Indiana
Otterbein Real Estate and Local Guide
A small rural town platted in 1872 and part of the Lafayette metropolitan area, straddling the Benton and Tippecanoe county line. Ranked Realty pairs verified local data with the agents who know Otterbein best.
About the area
Living in Otterbein, IN
Nicknamed "The Town Between Two Counties," known for an extremely wide, block-long Main Street with two rows of parking down the middle.
The housing market
Homes in Otterbein
- About 72% of housing units are owner-occupied.
- About 83% of housing is single-family homes.
- The median home value is about $137,400.
Landmarks and lifestyle
What makes Otterbein home
Otterbein Town Park
Town park at Fifth and Brown Streets with courts, a pavilion, and playground equipment
Otterbein Town Park
Tennis, pickleball, and basketball courts, an open-air pavilion, and children's play structures
Neighborhoods
Otterbein areas to know
Bolivar Township
The Benton County portion of the town
Shelby Township
The Tippecanoe County portion of the town
For agents
Own Otterbein in search and in AI
Buyers now ask Google and AI for a local agent. Claim your free Ranked Realty page for Otterbein, IN, get listed in our directory, and upgrade any time to a full AI-optimized site that gets you found and recommended.
Local facts on this page are verified against public sources as part of the AppWT local-data project. Data reflects the most recent available figures.